Click the tartan to view its entry in The Scottish Registers of Tartans which includes registration details, restrictions, and registrant information.
Unregistered tartans may link to one of the web's online design environments for similar information.
For any questions about reproduction of designs or weaving of these tartans, please contact the registrant directly or via this website.
Confidence Trickster Day
"Each clan, in ancient times, possessed a pattern, which it preserved with reverential care, regarding it as a distinguishing badge of its race and descent."
~ The Vestiarium Scoticum, 1842, John Sobieski Stuart and Charles Edward Stuart
Well... maybe, and maybe not! Tartan has one of the most fascinating histories when it comes to patterns and fabrics. Beyond its role in regional artisanship, cultural identity, kinship, and political affiliation, tartan has also been central to one of the most successful and audacious cons in recent history. The Sobieski Stuarts, a pair of 19th-century confidence tricksters, masterfully exploited the burgeoning Victorian interest in Scottish heritage to weave an elaborate con centered on tartan fabric. Claiming to be direct descendants of the exiled Stuart kings, John Sobieski Stuart and his brother Charles Edward Stuart ingratiated themselves with the Scottish elite. They produced a fabricated manuscript, the "Vestiarium Scoticum," supposedly detailing the ancient clan tartans of Scotland, preserved through their royal lineage. This convincing manuscript, complete with color illustrations, spurred a wave of tartan mania, with clans and individuals adopting these patterns—some with legitimate regional or historical antecedents, and others invented by the Sobieski Stuarts in consultation with weaving houses—to assert their heritage.
The Sobieski Stuarts' ruse not only elevated their social standing and financial gain but also sparked a broader and enduring fascination with Scottish culture and identity that continues today. It's worth noting that many Highland clan tartans have documented histories predating the Sobieski Stuarts' influence, while others were standardized or adopted during the late Victorian era when interest in Highland culture was revived. Organizations like the Scottish Register of Tartans work to authenticate and preserve these designs, blending genuine historical patterns with those that have become culturally significant over time. The Sobieski Stuarts now somewhat ironically even have their own tartan, celebrating both their role in the tartan revival and the historic links between Poland and Scotland. This tartan includes the red and white of the Polish national flag and the black and silver of the Royal Sobieski eagle. Fashion, Fraud, and a Fait Accompli! 🏴 🇵🇱 🦅
The Sobieski Stuarts, also known as John Sobieski Stuart and Charles Edward Stuart, were two brothers, John Hay Allan and Charles Manning Allen, who claimed to be descendants of the Royal House of Stuart. Their real names, however, were John Carter Allen and Charles Stuart Allen. They gained notoriety in the 19th century for their elaborate genealogical and historical claims, which were later revealed to be largely fabricated.
Origins and Claims
The Sobieski Stuarts' story begins with their father, Thomas Allen, who served in the Royal Navy and claimed a connection to the Stuart dynasty through his mother, who was supposedly an illegitimate daughter of Prince Charles Edward Stuart, known as Bonnie Prince Charlie. The brothers adopted the names John Sobieski Stuart and Charles Edward Stuart to emphasize their purported royal lineage. They traveled extensively in Scotland, gathering support and interest from those who romanticized the Jacobite cause and the Stuart heritage.
The Vestiarium Scoticum
One of the most significant contributions of the Sobieski Stuarts to Scottish culture was the publication of the "Vestiarium Scoticum" in 1842. This book claimed to be a 16th-century manuscript containing descriptions and illustrations of ancient Scottish clan tartans. The brothers presented the work as an authentic record of Scottish tartans passed down through the centuries. The "Vestiarium Scoticum" played a significant role in popularizing the idea of distinct clan tartans, which became a hallmark of Scottish identity and heritage.
Controversy and Exposure
Despite their initial success and the enthusiasm of their supporters, the Sobieski Stuarts' claims began to unravel under scrutiny. Scholars and historians started to question the authenticity of the "Vestiarium Scoticum" and the brothers' genealogical assertions. In 1847, the Scottish antiquary William Forbes Skene published a critical review of the "Vestiarium Scoticum," exposing numerous inaccuracies and anachronisms in the work. Skene's investigation revealed that the manuscript was a fabrication, based on dubious sources and creative embellishments by the Sobieski Stuarts themselves.
Legacy and Impact
The exposure of the Sobieski Stuarts' fraud did not entirely diminish their impact on Scottish culture. While their genealogical claims were discredited, the idea of clan tartans gained a lasting place in Scottish tradition. The "Vestiarium Scoticum," despite its dubious origins, contributed to the romantic revival of Highland culture and the enduring fascination with tartans and clan identity.
For more on this elaborate ruse, click the brothers' self-protrait, painted at Eilean Algas, a house on the estate of Lord Lovat.
The self-portrait was likely created around the 1840s, a period when the brothers were deeply immersed in their efforts to present themselves as legitimate heirs of the Stuart dynasty. The painting reflects their attempt to solidify their royal claims visually. It showcases the brothers in dignified, almost regal poses, dressed in elaborate attire that emphasizes their purported noble heritage. The choice of clothing and the style of the portrait are reminiscent of the romanticized Jacobite era, further reinforcing their fabricated connection to the Stuarts.